Study Shabbat folio 6A with parallel Hebrew-English text, traditional commentary, and modern study tools. Free access to Babylonian Talmud online.
as the halakha there is just as it is in the case of one who transfers an object in the public domain. There, even though as long as he takes it and walks and does not place the object he is exempt, is it not the case that when he places it he is liable? Obviously, between the place where he lifted
The Talmud rejects this comparison: Is this comparable? There, anywhere that he places the object is a place of potential liability. That cannot be described as two places of liability with an exempt domain between them, as the area between them is also a place of potential liability if he were to
Again the question arises: Where is there a precedent of liability for transferring an object through an exempt domain? The Talmud answers: Rather, it is possible to cite a different precedent: The halakha here is just as it is in the case of one who transfers an object in the public domain from th
Again the Talmud rejects the analogy: Is that similar? There, in the public domain, for this man it is an exempt domain, as it is within 4 cubits of the place that he lifted the object. However, for the entire world, it is a place of potential liability, as the space itself is a public domain and
Rather, it is possible to cite a different precedent: The halakha here is just as it is in the case of one who carries out an object from the private domain to the public domain through the sides of the public domain. The sides of a public domain are narrow strips located adjacent to the houses wh