Study Shabbat folio 100B with parallel Hebrew-English text, traditional commentary, and modern study tools. Free access to Babylonian Talmud online.
Isn’t that what we learned in the Mishnah, with regard to which R' Yoḥanan said: That liability is when it came to rest atop something, which means that the object must actually land in order for the one who threw it to be liable. Mareimar said to Ravina: Are you saying it is a case of rolling? O
Mishnah: One who throws an object 4 cubits into the sea is exempt. If there was a swamp and the public domain passes through it, one who throws an object 4 cubits into it is liable like one who carried 4 cubits in the public domain. And how deep is this swamp? It is less than 10 handbreadths deep.
Talmud: One of the rabbis said to Rava: Granted, passing passing is mentioned twice in the Mishnah; this teaches us that passage under duress is considered passage, but usage under duress is not considered usage. But why do I need it to mention swamp swamp twice? Rava answered him: One case is re
Abaye said: It is possible to explain this other way. It was necessary for the Mishnah to state swamp twice because it would have entered your mind to say that these matters apply specifically where the swamp is not 4 cubits wide because then people walk through the swamp and do not circumvent it,
Rav Ashi said another explanation: It was necessary for the Mishnah to state swamp twice because it would have entered your mind to say that these matters apply specifically where the swamp is at least 4 handbreadths wide, but where the swamp is not 4 handbreadths wide, people step over it and do no