Sanhedrin 70A

Study Sanhedrin folio 70A with parallel Hebrew-English text, traditional commentary, and modern study tools. Free access to Babylonian Talmud online.

Text Excerpt

The reason is that all are found frequently with her in sin, and in the end she will be a sinner and cause others to sin. But it is a Torah edict that the penalty for rebelliousness is imposed only upon a son, and not upon a daughter.

Mishnah: From when is a stubborn and rebellious son liable? From when he eats a tarteimar of meat and drinks a half-log of Italian wine. R' Yosei says: From when he eats a maneh of meat and drinks a log of wine.

The Mishnah now lists a series of conditions concerning his eating and drinking. If he ate these items with a group assembled for the performance of a mitzva, or he ate them at a meal celebrating the intercalation of a month, or he ate the items when they had second tithe status, in Jerusalem, he

The Mishnah summarizes: If he ate an item that involves performing a mitzva or an item that involves committing a transgression, or if he ate any food in the world but did not eat meat, or if he drank any beverage but did not drink wine, he does not become a stubborn and rebellious son, unless he

Talmud: R' Zeira says: Concerning this tarteimar that is mentioned in the Mishnah, I do not know what its measure is. But since R' Yosei is found to have doubled the measure of the wine, as the unattributed opinion in the Mishnah speaks of a half-log whereas R' Yosei requires a log, he presumably